I'll text you 3 real MLS comps in 24 hours.
Get comps
St. Pete Home Guide

Broadwater vs Bayway Isles: Which St. Pete Waterfront Neighborhood Fits You?

Broadwater vs Bayway Isles compared on price, flood risk, lifestyle & commute — honest advice from a licensed St. Pete agent.

By Luke Salm·8 min read·Updated October 19, 2026
Broadwater · context

On the map

A wider view of the neighborhood and its boundaries.

Loading map…

If you want canal access, a tight-knit civic community, and top-dollar waterfront value without crossing into ultra-luxury territory, Broadwater is your neighborhood. If you want a private gated estate island — 24-hour guard-gate security, prestige addresses on Boca Ciega Bay, and the highest flood insurance costs in the metro — Bayway Isles is in a class of its own. These two Southwest St. Pete waterfront neighborhoods look similar on a map but serve very different buyers.


Quick Comparison

BroadwaterBayway Isles
Single-family price rangeHigh-$600Ks to $2M+About $1M to $8M (estates)
Flood zonePrimarily Zone AEZone VE (coastal wave action)
Flood insurance est.$1,200–$3,500/yr (NFIP AE)$4,000–$12,000+/yr (NFIP VE)
Vibe / lifestyleCivic-minded canal neighborhood, active boating communityUltra-private gated estate island, ~200 SFH families
WalkabilityCar-dependent, bikeableCar-dependent, no nearby retail
Best forBoaters, move-up buyers, established familiesLuxury estate buyers, privacy-seekers, serious boaters
Watch-outsAging 1960s–70s stock; verify sailboat water lot-by-lotHighest flood insurance tier in St. Pete; very thin resale market; long days on market

Prices: What Your Money Actually Buys

Broadwater's palm and oak-lined streets are filled with ranch-style homes, often with Spanish or Mediterranean influences, and coastal contemporary houses — most built in the early 1970s — ranging from the high-$600,000s for a three-bedroom over 2,000 sq ft to more than $2 million for a five-bedroom waterfront home over 4,000 sq ft. The sweet spot is a four-bedroom canal home with a dock, priced between those two ends.

That's legitimate appreciation territory — and the neighborhood has staying power. But homes in Broadwater typically take longer to sell than the national average, which tells me buyers here are selective and willing to hold out for the right property. Sellers need to price sharply.

Bayway Isles operates in a different stratosphere entirely. Single-family homes range from classic Florida ranch styles to Mediterranean and modern estates, many with private docks, with prices generally starting around $1 million and reaching $8 million. Homes here typically take even longer to sell than in Broadwater, and waterfront estate listings can sit far longer still. That is a thin, patient market. Don't overprice it.

One key nuance: condos in communities like Bacopa Bay and Isla Key offer water views, pools, fitness centers and tennis courts, with prices typically ranging from the mid-$100,000s to about $1.2 million. These condo buildings skew Bayway Isles' blended neighborhood median downward significantly — so make sure you're comparing apples to apples when using any automated valuation tool.


Flood & Insurance: The Biggest Cost Difference Nobody Talks About Enough

This is where I have to be direct, because the gap between these two neighborhoods is enormous and consistently underestimated by buyers.

Broadwater sits primarily in FEMA Zone AE — the standard high-risk floodplain covering the 1%-annual-chance event. NFIP premiums in Zone AE typically run $1,200–$3,500/yr for a standard St. Pete single-family with $250K building coverage (the NFIP maximum) under FEMA's Risk Rating 2.0 methodology, which prices individual property risk rather than just zone averages. That's meaningful, but it's manageable and predictable.

Bayway Isles is a different story entirely. Bayway Isles carries Zone VE exposure — the most expensive flood insurance category — where premiums of $4,000–$12,000+/yr are common on the barrier islands, and some properties push even higher after the 2024 storms.

Private markets are thinner here, and post-Helene/Milton, several carriers pulled back from VE exposure entirely. On a $3M–$5M Bayway Isles estate, expect flood premiums at the top of that VE range or beyond once you add excess coverage above the NFIP's $250K building limit, before you touch homeowner's insurance. Request an elevation certificate and get a flood quote before you make an offer — not after inspection.

The good news: a home elevated 3 feet above BFE can see premiums drop sharply compared to an at-grade structure in the same zone. In Bayway Isles, construction details and elevation vary dramatically home to home. I pull elevation certificates and estimated premium ranges for every waterfront buyer client before we write a contract.

Both neighborhoods sit within Pinellas County's ongoing FEMA flood declaration. For any new construction or substantially improved building in Zone AE or VE, the lowest floor must be at or above the Base Flood Elevation, and Pinellas County adds an extra layer requiring all new or substantially improved buildings to be built to BFE plus one additional foot. That "freeboard" rule has major implications for renovation budgets on the older 1960s–1970s homes that dominate both neighborhoods.


Lifestyle & Who Lives There

Broadwater feels like a real neighborhood — not a resort enclave. The Broadwater Civic Association runs 23 block captains and counts roughly 215 paid member households, an unusually organized level of engagement for a single-family neighborhood.

It skews older and affluent, with household incomes well above the national average. You'll find retirees, established professionals, and long-time St. Pete families who know each other by name and wave from their docks. Broadwater's reputation for true sailboat water is real, but it depends on the specific canal, so always verify before you make an offer if no-fixed-bridge access is on your must-have list. Residents also enjoy multi-car garages, brick-lined driveways, and large lot sizes averaging around 10,000 square feet to more than a quarter-acre.

Bayway Isles is private by design — not accidentally quiet, but architecturally and institutionally private. Bayway Isles is a residential neighborhood consisting of two islands in the southwestern part of St. Petersburg, home to almost 200 families.

Bayway Isles is a guarded, deed-restricted community with a 24-hour staffed gate. Bayway Isles is ideal for boaters, with easy access to Boca Ciega Bay, Egmont Key, and downtown St. Pete. This is where people move when they've made it and want to keep a low profile. Expect neighbors who are semi-retired executives, successful business owners, and out-of-state buyers using it as a primary winter residence. The community is tiny — ~200 single-family homes — which creates an intimacy of its own kind, even if it's a quiet one.


Getting Around

Neither of these neighborhoods will win a walkability award, and I won't pretend otherwise.

Broadwater is considered car-dependent and bikeable with minimal transit options. That said, its position in southwest St. Pete puts you within a short drive of Gulfport's restaurant row, Eckerd College, Fort De Soto Park, and I-275 for Tampa commuters. Broadwater has 6 parks for recreational activities. Downtown St. Pete's Central Avenue scene is about 15–20 minutes without traffic — far enough to be peaceful, close enough to be practical.

Bayway Isles is even more isolated by geography. The community extends southward from the Pinellas Bayway causeway into the waters of southern Boca Ciega Bay — essentially a dead-end peninsula with one way in and one way out. Every errand is a planned car trip. The Bayway connects quickly to I-275 and Gulf beaches, and Sarasota is accessible without going through downtown, so commuters heading south or north to Tampa will find it reasonable. Just don't move here expecting to pop out for coffee on foot.


Who Should Choose Broadwater vs Bayway Isles

Choose Broadwater if you:

  • Have a budget of $800K–$2M and want genuine waterfront value without paying a prestige premium.
  • Want sailboat-water canal access and a living, active boating community around you.
  • Value a neighborhood with civic identity — block captains, community events, neighbors who actually know each other.
  • Are renovating a 1970s ranch in a neighborhood where updated homes stand out and appraise well.
  • Can plan around Zone AE flood costs in the $1,200–$3,500/yr range.

Choose Bayway Isles if you:

  • Have a budget of $2M–$8M and privacy, security, and a prestige address are non-negotiable.
  • Are buying a trophy property — a dock-and-pool estate that makes a statement.
  • Are a serious boater who wants direct, unrestricted bay access from your own backyard.
  • Fully understand and can absorb Zone VE flood insurance costs ($4,000–$12,000+/yr) as part of your total cost of ownership.
  • Are comfortable with a thin resale market and long days-on-market — you're playing a long game here, not a flip.

My honest verdict: Broadwater offers better dollar-for-dollar value and a more connected lifestyle for the vast majority of waterfront buyers in the $1M–$2M range. Bayway Isles offers unmatched privacy and prestige for those where cost is secondary to quality of life — but go in with eyes wide open on flood insurance, illiquidity, and the ongoing carrying costs of a VE-zone estate. If you're genuinely on the fence, Broadwater is the smarter entry point into southwest St. Pete waterfront living.


Let Me Pull Real Comps Before You Decide

Zillow's Zestimate won't tell you whether a specific Broadwater canal lot has true sailboat clearance, or what an elevation certificate on a particular Bayway Isles address actually means for your annual flood premium. I run that research before my clients make offers — not after.

Request free MLS comps for Broadwater or Bayway Isles → or call/text me directly to talk through your budget and priorities. I'm Luke Salm, RE/MAX Champions — licensed in Pinellas, Pasco, Hillsborough, and Manatee County, and I know these canals personally.

What's your St. Pete home actually worth?

Zillow's guess can be off by tens of thousands. Tell me where to send it and I'll pull 3 real MLS comps — actual recent sales near you — and email them within 24 hours. Free, no obligation, no pressure to list.

Unsubscribe anytime. Your email is never shared.

Frequently Asked Questions

Real questions Luke gets from buyers and sellers in this area.

Bayway Isles single-family homes are significantly pricier, with estates generally running from around $1M up to about $8M. Broadwater single-family homes range from the high-$600Ks to $2M+ — still luxury, but a full price tier below Bayway Isles estates.
Luke Salm, licensed Florida real estate agent at RE/MAX CHAMPIONS serving Tampa Bay

Thinking about a move in St. Pete?

I'm Luke. I live in Shore Acres, I sell across St. Pete and Tampa Bay, and I'm here to help when you're ready.

Related